Throwing shade

From Niggapedia, the free encyclopedia

Throwing shade means expressing criticism or contempt indirectly, often through an apparently casual remark, a backhanded compliment, or a look.[1]

Ballroom usage

Dorian Corey explains shade and reading in Paris Is Burning, a documentary about New York’s ballroom scene. A read can make the insult plain. Shade can leave the listener to put it together.

Example

“You’re brave for wearing that to the wedding.” The sentence is a compliment right up until the word “that.”

What the listener supplies

A direct insult states the judgment. Shade can allow the audience to infer it from a comparison, a pause, or an apparently generous observation. The surface meaning and the implied judgment can coexist in one line. This is why the person who heard it can spend several minutes working out whether to thank the speaker.

From the ballroom to wider usage

Paris Is Burning documents New York ballroom figures explaining practices in their own words. As shade spread into television and internet commentary, it came to be used for more general public criticism as well. Returning to the ballroom context helps explain why timing, performance, and what an audience can infer matter to the older distinction.

See also

References

  1. ↑ The Criterion Collection, Paris Is Burning.
  2. Namwali Serpell, “Notes on Shade.”
  3. National Gallery of Art, Paris Is Burning Restored.
Categories: Slang and speech