A communal cup with a brief but well-documented period of public ownership.[1]
Transfer of ownership
The cup begins in the center of the table. One person takes a sip and leaves it next to their phone. Under the customary law of adjacent objects, it is now their cup.
Restitution
When challenged, the new owner offers to put the cup back. The rest of the table declines on the grounds that it has been returned in a materially different condition.
Documentary record
All witnesses recall hearing “this is for everybody.” None recall being offered any.
The central table
The first stage of sharing depends on where the cup sits. Placing it in the middle suggests a common supply and requires everyone to reach equally far. Someone moves it to make room for a plate, then moves the plate. By this point the original arrangement survives mainly in the recollection of the person who paid for the bottle.
Proposal for individual cups
A second round of negotiations often yields a radical proposal to give every person a separate cup. This would make ownership clear and remove the need to audit each sip. The proposal is generally adopted once everybody has a cup except the person who kept asking for one.
See also
References
- ↑ Committee on Shared Beverages. Meeting minutes, cut short when the cup left the table.
- Derek. “I Thought That Was Mine.” Personal communication.